Atropisomers in InChI

Some biaryls cannot rotate about the bond between their rings. Their two twisted forms are mirror images that can be separated in a bottle. Standard InChI gives both the same identifier. The new InChI tells them apart.

M /t11-/m0/s1
P /t11-/m1/s1

2,2'-Dibromo-6,6'-dichlorobiphenyl. Standard InChI has no stereo layer for either form: both are InChI=1S/C12H6Br2Cl2/c13-7-3-1-5-9(15)11(7)12-8(14)4-2-6-10(12)16/h1-6H.

What an atropisomer is

Two flat rings joined by a single bond normally spin freely. Bulky groups next to that bond, in the ortho positions, collide when the rings try to pass each other. The molecule stays twisted one way or the other. The bond becomes a chirality axis, like the axis of an allene.

The two forms are named M and P (minus and plus, the sense of the twist), or aR and aS by CIP rules (M = aR, P = aS). InChI writes neither name: it records the twist as a sign in /t and the mirror image in /m, as for any stereocentre.

Whether rotation is slow enough to isolate the forms is chemistry, not something InChI computes. InChI decides from the structure alone, with the rules below.

From drawing to InChI, step by step

Example: the M form above.

  1. You draw the twist

    A wedge on a ring bond at the axis shows which edge of that ring points toward you. Two wedges (one per ring) are usual. One wedge is enough, and 3D coordinates work without any wedge.

    Atropisomers are detected only with the option -EnhancedStereochemistry. Without it, the output is exactly the standard InChI.

  2. InChI looks for an axis

    A bond is a candidate when all of these hold:

    • It is a single bond between two carbons.
    • Each carbon has three non-hydrogen neighbours and no H (a flat, aryl-like end).
    • The bond is not in a ring of 6 atoms or fewer.

    axis   the four ortho positions

  3. InChI checks that rotation is blocked

    At least three of the four ortho positions must carry something other than H. A fused ring counts. When the axis sits inside a ring of exactly 8 atoms, the two bridge positions are enough.

    Three ortho groups: axis found /t10-/m0/s1
    Two ortho groups: no axis
  4. InChI checks that each end is unsymmetric

    The two ortho groups on each ring must differ. If one ring has the same group on both sides, turning it over gives the same molecule: there is no mirror-image pair.

    Here one ring has Cl on both sides. Fully hindered, but not chiral: no axis.

  5. InChI reads the twist

    From the wedges (or the 3D coordinates) InChI computes a parity for the axis, by the same method it uses for allenes. If the drawing is flat, the twist is unknown and the axis is left out, with the warning:

    Warning (Omitted undefined stereo)
  6. InChI writes the axis once

    The two axis carbons get canonical numbers 11 and 12. The axis appears once in /t, on the lower-numbered carbon. Citing both would read like two stereocentres.

    InChI=1B/C12H6Br2Cl2/c13-7-3-1-5-9(15)11(7)12-8(14)4-2-6-10(12)16/h1-6H/t11-/m0/s1
    /t11-
    an axis on carbons 11–12; with one stereo element the sign is always −
    /m0
    which mirror image: /m0 is M, /m1 is P
    /s1
    absolute configuration, as in standard InChI
    15951371311121016624814
  7. Check: draw it with one wedge

    Remove the second wedge. The twist is still defined, and the InChI is identical:

    /t11-/m0/s1

Rules at a glance

Carbon–carbon single bonds only

Both ends flat, three-connected, without H. C–N, N–N and C–O axes are not detected yet.

Not in a small ring

A bond in a ring of 6 atoms or fewer is never an axis.

Three of four ortho positions

Substituted, or part of a fused ring. Two are enough inside an 8-membered ring.

Each end unsymmetric

Two equal ortho groups on one ring: no axis.

One wedge, two wedges or 3D

All give the same InChI. A flat drawing gives no axis and a warning.

Written once, in /t

On the lower-numbered axis carbon. The mirror image is in /m.

/t11-/m0/s1

M is /m0, P is /m1

For every M/P-labelled molecule in the test set, 2D and 3D alike.

Prefix 1B

Marks the string as enhanced (beta), never mistaken for a standard InChI.

Strings are shown from the first stereo layer on.

3D coordinates, torsion +44°
11731591315128426101416

No wedges needed: the 3D geometry fixes the axis. +44° is P.

New InChI
/t11-/m1/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
3D coordinates, torsion −44°
11731591315128426101416

The mirror image, M.

New InChI
/t11-/m0/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
(M)-BINOL
22182016141012211719151351378426119

Fused rings count as ortho substituents: each naphthyl end has two.

New InChI
/t19-/m0/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
(P)-BINOL
22182016141012211719151351378426119

Its enantiomer: only /m changes.

New InChI
/t19-/m1/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
Lignan, axis inside an 8-membered ring
2311151612713192014835179101864211222

An 8-ring holds the biaryl twisted, so the two bridge positions suffice. The two CH centres (15, 16) are not wedged in this file, so they read ?.

New InChI
/t15?,16?,19-/m0/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
No ring at all
1314912101134781256

Axes need not involve aromatic rings: four branched groups hinder this C–C bond.

New InChI
/t13-/m1/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
Aryl–carbonyl axis of an amide
1081169712131434251

The C=O carbon is a flat, three-connected end like an aryl carbon.

New InChI
/t11-/m1/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer
(M)-6,6'-dinitrodiphenic acid, a classic
711951381210642141920162324152122131718

The first resolved atropisomer (Christie and Kenner, 1922).

New InChI
/t11-/m0/s1
Standard InChI
no stereo layer

or and & labels on an axis

The labels of enhanced stereochemistry work on an axis as on a stereocentre: &1 for both forms mixed (racemic), or1 for one form, unknown which.

15951371311121016624814

&1 on the axis: racemic. No /m.

/t11-/s3

or1 instead: /t11-/s2

15951371311121016624814

The label must sit on the lower-numbered axis carbon

Here or1 sits on carbon 12. InChI does not see it and writes the drawn form as absolute, without a warning:

/t11-/m0/s1

What is not detected

In each case the new InChI equals the standard one.

71195138121064214161513
Both wedges on one side
The drawing contradicts itself; the axis counts as undefined and is left out.
No axis in the InChI.
361121014111315742985
Biaryl bridged into a 7-ring, no other substituent
Only two ortho positions are substituted, and the ring flips quickly at room temperature.
No axis in the InChI.
135911710841226
3,3'-Bipyridine
No ortho substituent: the rings rotate freely.
No axis in the InChI.
171119814921181516132011271062345
Aryl–N axis (N-aryl indole)
Version 1 covers carbon–carbon axes only. C–N, N–N and C–O axes come later.
No axis in the InChI.
21191715131179532220181614128106412
N–N axis (2,2'-diethyl-1,1'-biindole)
Same: not carbon–carbon.
No axis in the InChI.
22172823201524181621192784516273132510121426911
Overcrowded alkene
The twist is around a C=C bond, which InChI already records as E/Z in /b. No single-bond axis.
/b24-23-

Limits of this version

How to use it

Input. A molfile with a wedge on a ring bond next to the axis, on one or both sides, as for the biaryl above. 3D coordinates work without wedges.

Command line. Add -EnhancedStereochemistry:

$ inchi-1 biaryl.mol -STDIO -AuxNone -Key -EnhancedStereochemistry
InChI=1B/C12H6Br2Cl2/c13-7-3-1-5-9(15)11(7)12-8(14)4-2-6-10(12)16/h1-6H/t11-/m0/s1
InChIKey=XAIAIAZDMJCXKA-NSHDSACABA-N

Without the option the axis is not seen:

$ inchi-1 biaryl.mol -STDIO -AuxNone -Key
InChI=1S/C12H6Br2Cl2/c13-7-3-1-5-9(15)11(7)12-8(14)4-2-6-10(12)16/h1-6H
InChIKey=XAIAIAZDMJCXKA-UHFFFAOYSA-N

From a program, pass the option to the InChI library like any other, e.g. MakeINCHIFromMolfileText(molfile, "-EnhancedStereochemistry", &output) or in the options string of GetINCHI. The InChI starts with InChI=1B/: a beta feature, so the format can still change.